Okay, before I start with this post, let me issue my disclaimers ahead of time.
- I am not an economics expert.
- I don’t pretend to know how to solve the mortgage meltdown or present economic recession.
- The views I’ll be expressing in this post are simply observations from someone “in the trenches” of real estate, and a typical homeowner and taxpayer.
Shall we begin?
Oberservation #1: Where does the “buck” stop? Nobody seems to be taking responsibility for any of these financial disasters. Everybody (including Wall Street, banks and lenders, corporations, politicians, homeowners, renters, etc) points their finger at someone else and says, “You’re the one responsible for the mess I’m in. A fellow real estate agent emailed me this YouTube video the other day, and I think it pretty much sums up the rationale of many these days. I hope you get a chuckle out of it. http://americandigest.org/mt-archives/nota_bene/rats_if_id_just.php
Observation #2: If you throw enough “bucks” at the problem, it will get better. I’m assuming that the “experts” in charge of the bailouts know what they’re doing, but it seems to me that they’re just throwing money at the problem and hoping it heals itself. I keep hearing about these needy corporations and financial institutions, but I have yet to hear exactly how the bailout money they receive will be helping the rest of us peasants.
Observation #3: I also keep hearing talk about helping “homeowners in trouble” stay in their homes. Now I know this is a regional problem, but many of the “homeowners who are in trouble” don’t really want to stay in their home. Many need to move to a different part of the country in order to find work, and they need help selling their home, not keeping their home. Many, through no fault of their own, have found themselves owing more on the home than it’s currently worth. And most of those people that need to sell can’t afford to because that would mean that they’d have to cough up cash to bring to closing – cash that they simply do not have.
Now here’s where the real problem starts. Most lenders will not allow an owner to sell his home “short” (meaning selling for less than what he owes on his mortgage) unless he’s behind on his monthly mortgage payments. Therefore, a responsible homeowner who needs to move is stuck with the tough choice of either tryinig to keep current with his mortgage PLUS take on a rent payment in his new location where he has work, or else get into a default situation so that the lender will allow a short sale. Even then, many lenders will proceed with the foreclosure process rather than allow a short sale.
Now this is just my Jane the Real Estate Agent observation but it seems to me that lenders would be far ahead in the game if they encouraged homeowners to stay current on their mortgages but still allow them to short sell at current market value. I say this because once the home is in foreclosure the lender has lost months of payments from the homeowner, the owner has ruined his credit, and the home will end up being sold for less than market value because lenders want these bank owned properties sold as quickly as possible, which means pricing them below current market value.
To me, jobs are crucial to help homeowners be able to stay in their homes. Many of the folks losing their homes right now are the very people that helped build those houses. Those in the construction trades have been particularly hurt by the housing downturn – a double whammy, if you will. If the owner(s) have jobs, then they can generally afford to pay the mortgage and they won’t have to move.
Observation #4: Not all the people in foreclosure are homeowners. Many are investors that thought they could flip the house for a profit. As the market started to decline, the smart investors bailed. However some of the less experienced (or naïve, or sometimes greedy) investors thought they could ride out the downturn and make more money in a few months when the market recovered. Of course I don’t think anybody saw this housing decline as lasting as long as it has been or being as devastating as it has been in some parts of the country.
Observation #5: Regular, responsible homeowners may soon be in trouble. Those that took out a conventional 5/1 ARM or 7/1 ARM are now faced with those resetting to higher rates. Now these aren’t subprime interest only loans I’m referring to, but Alt-A’s. Many homeowners assumed that they’d either sell their home or refinance these adjustable rate mortgages before they reset to current rates, and many are now facing higher monthly payments. These homeowners are generally current on their mortgage with good FICO scores, but the higher rates may result in mortgage payments that are no longer manageable. As Ordinary Jane the Real Estate Agent I have to ask why there hasn’t been some plan to allow these folks to refinance at current 30-year rates without penalty or fees. Here is a very interesting video about the mortgage crisis and why it may get worse before it gets better. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pmeBSWI9sF8
Observation #6: Despite all this doom and gloom there may be a bright spot on the horizon. As the stock market continues it’s out-of-control roller coaster ride and as home prices have gotten so much lower lately, especially the bank owned properties, I think we’ll see a return of investors to the real estate market – not the same “fix and flip” or “buy and flip” guys we saw in 2004-2006, but rather long term investors purchasing rental properties with cash or small mortgages. It’s now possible to get a good rate of return because of the low purchase prices, and as more and more homeowners end up in default the demand for rentals should increase. At one of my continuing ed classes this past month, the instructor told of parents in Phoenix purchasing three bargain-priced properties as a sort of “college fund” for their toddlers. When the kids are ready for college, the properties will be sold to fund their education. As compared to the stock market a real estate investment is tangible, and some investors who have liquidity may decide that a long term real estate investment makes sense right now. This would be good news for folks trying to sell a starter home.
Observation #7: We all need to return to the mindset of past years when it comes to investing in real estate – that it’s a long term investment and that a home provides shelter for a family for many years. I’m not sure when the nation’s mindset changed from the Ozzie and Harriet middle-class home-to-raise-a-family-in to the recent mindset of mini-McMansions with granite countertops (in a kitchen that is seldom used) and special rooms for state-of-the-art media equipment (for those few times when the family can agree on a movie to watch together) and spa-type bathrooms with jetted tubs (that nobody uses because it’s always a quick shower and out the door we go). I don’t mean to be harsh, here, and we’ve all fallen victim to this latest and greatest trend of buying up every few years, but really when we look back on our childhood homes, can’t we be satisfied with less? Perhaps we could even be happier with less.
Observation #8: Yep, all the above has just been the personal opinion of Ordinary Jane – who has an opinion on the current state of housing.






